TEAM REVIEW: Crypt Custodian for PS5/Switch

Cross-platform reviews aren’t something we get to do all the time, so when we get the chance, it’s a treat to compare how a game performs across different systems. While modern technology suggests that games should be consistent across platforms, reality often reveals otherwise. With this curiosity in mind, my colleague and gaming aficionado Albert Eres joined me in diving into Crypt Custodian, the latest addition to the Metroidvania genre on both PC and consoles. For this review, I tackled the PS5 version, while Albert explored how the game fares on the Switch. So without further ado, let’s see if this quirky game hit the right notes on both devices.

Crypt Custodian tells the tale of a cat stuck in the afterlife, denied entry to heaven for reasons best left unexplained here. Instead, it finds itself tasked with cleaning up an unwelcoming netherworld, armed with nothing but a broom. The storyline, though whimsical and unusual, is well-crafted and doesn’t overburden itself with seriousness. The plot injects a touch of charm, lending depth to the various characters you meet, which is surprisingly tricky to achieve within the Metroidvania framework. This genre often gravitates toward intense action with sparse or genre-fitting narratives. Seeing a fresh take like this is a breath of fresh air.

One standout feature of Crypt Custodian is its departure from traditional side-scrolling gameplay. Many Metroidvanias are rooted in platform mechanics, but this one opts for a top-down adventure style. If you’ve ever played Zelda: A Link to the Past, you’ll have an idea of what to expect. I find that this perspective allows for more precise movement, effectively reducing the typical frustrations associated with platform games.

As is typical in Metroidvanias, you can’t immediately access every part of the map from the start. While backtracking is necessary, it ensures that you’re not overwhelmed too soon. It cleverly locks regions until you’ve developed the skills to conquer them, creating a controlled yet exploratory experience. The game isn’t linear, but it prevents you from venturing too far into uncharted territory before you’re ready, making exploration both manageable and rewarding.

Crypt Custodian excels in blending action with puzzle-solving elements. If you’re inclined to jump into the fray, there’s enough combat to satisfy without driving you to despair. Likewise, the game’s puzzles challenge you just the right amount, encouraging that “ah-ha” moment without being excessively convoluted. Typically, if you’re stuck, a subtle overlook is likely the culprit, not your understanding. This balance makes for an engaging pace, maintaining your interest without unnecessary frustration.

A delightful aspect of Crypt Custodian lies in its collectibles, adding layers to its gameplay. From upgrade points hidden behind puzzles to elusive cats trapped in jars, there’s plenty to discover. Collecting these cats rewards you when returned to their mother, offering a nice change of pace from the main quest. Convenient warp points scattered across the map facilitate this backtracking, so revisiting areas becomes a pleasure, not a chore.

Finding these warp points is crucial—they serve as lifelines where you can save progress, equip abilities, and teleport. Their locations remain unknown until discovered, adding an adrenaline rush as you navigate new zones. When you’re on low health in dangerous, unknown areas, the sense of relief upon finding a warp point can be immense.

On the PS5, Crypt Custodian boasts charming, arcade-style graphics and smooth controls, paired with an enjoyable soundtrack. Although I’m hit-or-miss with Metroidvania titles, largely due to my distaste for platforming, this game kept my interest piqued. If you’re fond of this genre, Crypt Custodian will likely be right up your alley, evoking nostalgic 90s RPG vibes that resonate with many fond memories. For me, this game is a winner—a fantastic addition to my library that I’m eager to revisit.

Overall Score: 9/10

Now, turning to Albert Eres, he’s also found Crypt Custodian to be a refreshing entry in the action genre, which is heavily crowded with Soulslike games. Drawing inspiration from classic series like Zelda and Metroid, it stands out with its customizable features that resonate with casual gamers. Its narrative about a whimsical cat journey adds a layer of charm that can’t be overstated.

One commendable gameplay aspect in Crypt Custodian is its transparency with enemy attacks. Unlike some action games that expect players to predict attacks without warning—a nod to Soulslike games—this title marks where projectile-based attacks will land. It’s not about making combat easy, as some enemies will still give you a run for your money, but it adds an element of predictability suitable for those looking for a relaxed gaming session.

Another highlight is Crypt Custodian’s customizable assist options, allowing players to tweak combat difficulty, fall damage, and boost health levels. For many casual gamers, these options can mean the difference between completing a game and giving up in frustration. It’s always disheartening when a game with a compelling story and art style is abandoned due to its difficulty, a gap Crypt Custodian bridges expertly. Though some assist options on the Switch seem to reset unexpectedly, possibly a bug, the customization they offer is nonetheless significant.

Perhaps the best assist feature is the extended time for solving puzzles. Often, game difficulties focus on combat without accommodating puzzle-solving, but Crypt Custodian provides breathing room. Even with mostly optional timed puzzles—usually leading to upgrade points—it’s comforting to know you don’t need to be a platforming prodigy to enjoy them.

Crypt Custodian comes highly recommended for casual gamers, Zelda and Metroid fans, and cat enthusiasts. It’s a game filled with endearing features, with difficulty adjustments being just one aspect that enhances the overall experience.

Overall Score: 9/10

Ultimately, Crypt Custodian is a near-perfect tribute to classic RPG and puzzle gameplay. Engaging storyline, addictive gameplay, and an approach that doesn’t ramp up difficulty for its own sake mark its strengths. The fact that both Albert and I thoroughly enjoyed the game on two different platforms truly speaks to its quality. While it doesn’t revolutionize the genre, it certainly refines it. If Metroidvanias are your thing, this title is a must-have for your collection.